The Performance of Mixed Manufacturer Metal On Metal Total Hip Replacements
Keywords:Total Hip, Mix and Match, Metal on Metal
Using a femoral head from one manufacturer on the stem of another manufacturer poses the risk that the taper interface between the components may not contact correctly and the performance of the joint will be impaired. The cohorts in this study are a combination of modular Birmingham Hip Resurfacing (BHR) and Adept femoral heads on CPT stems. The study reviews the geometry of the taper interfaces to establish if the taper clearance angles was outside of the normal range for other taper interfaces. In addition the rates of material loss from the bearings and taper and a ranking of the stem damage were reviewed to determine if the levels of loss were above that seen for other similar joints.
The material loss analysis demonstrated that the rates or levels of loss from the bearings, taper and stem were no different to levels published for manufacturer matched joints and in many cases were lower. The results demonstrate that the taper clearance angles for the mixed manufacturer joints (BHR-CPT: 0.067 to -0.116, Adept-CPT: 0.101 to -0.056) were within the range of other studies and manufacturer matched clearances (0.134 to -0.149).Using components from different manufacturers has not in this instance increased the level of material loss from the joints, when compared to other similar manufacturer matched joints.
Kocagöz SB, Underwood RJ, Sivan S, Gilbert JL, MacDonald DW, Day JS, Kurtz SM. Does taper angle clearance influence fretting and corrosion damage at the head–stem interface? A matched cohort retrieval study. Seminars in arthroplasty. Vol. 24: Elsevier, 2013:246-54.
Langton DJ, Sidaginamale R, Lord JK, Nargol AV, Joyce TJ. Taper junction failure in large-diameter metal-on-metal bearings. Bone Joint Res 2012;1-4:56-63.
Bone MC, Sidaginamale RP, Lord JK, Scholes SC, Joyce TJ, Nargol AV, Langton DJ. Determining material loss from the femoral stem trunnion in hip arthroplasty using a coordinate measuring machine. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine 2015;229-1:69-76.
Glyn-Jones S, Pandit H, Kwon Y-M, Doll H, Gill HS, Murray DW. Risk factors for inflammatory pseudotumour formation following hip resurfacing. Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, British Volume 2009;91-B-12:1566-74.
Langton DJ, Jameson SS, Joyce TJ, Hallab NJ, Natu S, Nargol AVF. Early failure of metal-on-metal bearings in hip resurfacing and large-diameter total hip replacement: A CONSEQUENCE OF EXCESS WEAR. Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, British Volume 2010;92-B-1:38-46.
Matthies A, Underwood R, Cann P, Ilo K, Nawaz Z, Skinner J, Hart AJ. Retrieval analysis of 240 metal-on-metal hip components, comparing modular total hip replacement with hip resurfacing. Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, British Volume 2011;93-B-3:307-14.
Cook RB, Bolland BJRF, Wharton JA, Tilley S, Latham JM, Wood RJK. Pseudotumour Formation Due to Tribocorrosion at the Taper Interface of Large Diameter Metal on Polymer Modular Total Hip Replacements. Journal of Arthroplasty 2013;28-8:1430-6.
Gill IPS, Webb J, Sloan K, Beaver RJ. Corrosion at the neck-stem junction as a cause of metal ion release and pseudotumour formation. Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, British Volume 2012;94-B-7:895-900.
Fricka KB, Ho H, Peace WJ, Engh Jr CA. Metal-on-Metal Local Tissue Reaction Is Associated With Corrosion of the Head Taper Junction. The Journal of Arthroplasty 2012;27-8, Supplement:26-31.e1.
Lindgren JU, Brismar BH, Wikstrom AC. Adverse reaction to metal release from a modular metal-on-polyethylene hip prosthesis. Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, British Volume 2011;93-B-10:1427-30.
Mao X, Tay GH, Godbolt DB, Crawford RW. Pseudotumor in a Well-Fixed Metal-on-Polyethylene Uncemented Hip Arthroplasty. The Journal of Arthroplasty 2012;27-3:493.e13-.e17.
Bryant M, Ward M, Farrar R, Freeman R, Brummitt K, Nolan J, Neville A. Failure analysis of cemented metal-on-metal total hip replacements from a single centre cohort. Wear 2013;301-1-2:226-33.
Donell ST, Darrah C, Nolan JF, Wimhurst J, Toms A, Barker TH, Case CP, Tucker JK, Norwich Metal-on-Metal Study G. Early failure of the Ultima metal-on-metal total hip replacement in the presence of normal plain radiographs. J Bone Joint Surg Br 2010;92-11:1501-8.
Hothi HS, Berber R, Panagiotopoulos AC, Whittaker RK, Rhead C, Skinner JA, Hart AJ. Clinical significance of corrosion of cemented femoral stems in metal-on-metal hips: a retrieval study. International Orthopaedics 2016:1-8.
Glyn-Jones S, Roques A, Taylor A, Kwon YM, McLardy-Smith P, Gill HS, Walter W, Tuke M, Murray D. The in vivo linear and volumetric wear of hip resurfacing implants revised for pseudotumor. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2011;93-23:2180-8.
Kwon YM, Glyn-Jones S, Simpson DJ, Kamali A, McLardy-Smith P, Gill HS, Murray DW. Analysis of wear of retrieved metal-on-metal hip resurfacing implants revised due to pseudotumours. J Bone Joint Surg Br 2010;92-3:356-61.
Underwood RJ, Zografos A, Sayles RS, Hart A, Cann P. Edge loading in metal-on-metal hips: low clearance is a new risk factor. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine 2012:0954411911431397.
Matthies A, Skinner J, Osmani H, Henckel J, Hart A. Pseudotumors Are Common in Well-positioned Low-wearing Metal-on-Metal Hips. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research® 2012;470-7:1895-906.
Nawabi D, Nassif N, Do H, Stoner K, Elpers M, Su E, Wright T, Potter H, Padgett D. What Causes Unexplained Pain in Patients With Metal-on metal Hip Devices? A Retrieval, Histologic, and Imaging Analysis. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research® 2014;472-2:543-54.
Lord JK, Langton DJ, Nargol AVF, Joyce TJ. Volumetric wear assessment of failed metal-on-metal hip resurfacing prostheses. Wear 2011;272-1:79-87.
Matthies AK, Racasan R, Bills P, Blunt L, Cro S, Panagiotidou A, Blunn G, Skinner J, Hart AJ. Material loss at the taper junction of retrieved large head metal-on-metal total hip replacements. J Orthop Res 2013;31-11:1677-85.
Morlock MM, Bishop N, Zustin J, Hahn M, Rüther W, Amling M. Modes of Implant Failure After Hip Resurfacing: Morphological and Wear Analysis of 267 Retrieval Specimens. Vol. 90, 2008:89-95.
Hothi HS, Whittaker RK, Meswania JM, Blunn GW, Skinner JA, Hart AJ. Influence of stem type on material loss at the metal-on-metal pinnacle taper junction. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine 2015;229-1:91-7.
Sidaginamale RP, Joyce TJ, Bowsher JG, Lord JK, Avery PJ, Natu S, Nargol AV, Langton DJ. The clinical implications of metal debris release from the taper junctions and bearing surfaces of metal-on-metal hip arthroplasty: joint fluid and blood metal ion concentrations. Bone Joint J 2016;98-b-7:925-33.
Hothi HS, Matthies AK, Berber R, Whittaker RK, Skinner JA, Hart AJ. The Reliability of a Scoring System for Corrosion and Fretting, and Its Relationship to Material Loss of Tapered, Modular Junctions of Retrieved Hip Implants. The Journal of Arthroplasty 2014;29-6:1313-7.
Brock TM, Sidaginamale R, Rushton S, Nargol AVF, Bowsher JG, Savisaar C, Joyce TJ, Deehan DJ, Lord JK, Langton DJ. Shorter, rough trunnion surfaces are associated with higher taper wear rates than longer, smooth trunnion surfaces in a contemporary large head metal-on-metal total hip arthroplasty system. Journal of Orthopaedic Research 2015;33-12:1868-74.
Hothi HS, Eskelinen AP, Berber R, Lainiala OS, Moilanen TPS, Skinner JA, Hart AJ. Factors Associated With Trunnionosis in the Metal-on-Metal Pinnacle Hip. The Journal of Arthroplasty.
Cook RB, Shearwood-Porter NR, Latham JM, Wood RJK. Volumetric assessment of material loss from retrieved cemented metal hip replacement stems. Tribology International 2015;89:105-8.
Hart AJ, Ilo K, Underwood R, Cann P, Henckel J, Lewis A, Cobb J, Skinner J. The relationship between the angle of version and rate of wear of retrieved metal-on-metal resurfacings: A PROSPECTIVE, CT-BASED STUDY. Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, British Volume 2011;93-B-3:315-20.
Witt F, Bosker BH, Bishop NE, Ettema HB, Verheyen CCPM, Morlock MM. The Relation Between Titanium Taper Corrosion and Cobalt-Chromium Bearing Wear in Large-Head Metal-on-Metal Total Hip Prostheses. Vol. 96, 2014:e157.
Tuke M, Taylor A, Roques A, Maul C. 3D linear and volumetric wear measurement on artificial hip joints—Validation of a new methodology. Precision Engineering 2010;34-4:777-83.
Cook RB, Maul C, Strickland AM. Validation of an Optical CMM for the Measurement of Wear at the Taper Interface in Total Hip Replacement. ASTM STP1591 Modularity and Tapers in Total Joint Replacement Devices 2015.
Bisseling P, Tan T, Lu Z, Campbell PA, van Susante JLC. The absence of a metal-on-metal bearing does not preclude the formation of a destructive pseudotumor in the hip—a case report. Acta Orthopaedica 2013;84-4:437-41.
Windler M. Korrosionsverhalten von modularen Verbindungen bei Hüftprothesen. Departement Werkstoffe. ETH Zurich, 2003.
Kamali A. Hip Joint Tribology. In: McMinn DW, ed. Modern Hip Resurfacing: Springer London, 2009:79-89.
Hu XQ, Wood RJK, Taylor A, Tuke MA. The tribological behaviour of different clearance MOM hip joints with lubricants of physiological viscosities. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine 2011;225-11:1061-9.
McMinn DJW. Modern Hip Resurfacing. Springer London, 2009.
Willert HG, Broback LG, Buchhorn GH, Jensen PH, Koster G, Lang I, Ochsner P, Schenk R. Crevice corrosion of cemented titanium alloy stems in total hip replacements. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1996-333:51-75.
Howell JR, Blunt LA, Doyle C, Hooper RM, Lee AJC, Ling RSM. In Vivo surface wear mechanisms of femoral components of cemented total hip arthroplasties: the influence of wear mechanism on clinical outcome. The Journal of arthroplasty 2004;19-1:88-101.
Bolland BJ, Culliford DJ, Langton DJ, Millington JP, Arden NK, Latham JM. High failure rates with a large-diameter hybrid metal-on-metal total hip replacement: clinical, radiological and retrieval analysis. J Bone Joint Surg Br 2011;93-5:608-15.
Thomas SR, Shukla D, Latham PD. Corrosion of cemented titanium femoral stems. J Bone Joint Surg Br 2004;86-7:974-8.
Burston BJ, Wood JH, Lewis JR, Prosser GH, Firth L, Wood DJ, Yates PJ. High Failure Rates of the Spectron EF Stem at a Minimum of 10 Year’s Follow-up. The Journal of Arthroplasty;29-10:1956-60.
How to Cite
Copyright (c) 2017 Richard Barker Cook, Jeremy M. Latham, Robert J.K. Wood
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Copyright and License Agreement:
Authors who publish with the Reconstructive Review agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work. Reconstructive Review follows the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial CC BY-NC. This license allows anyone to download works, build upon the material, and share them with others for non-commercial purposes as long as they credit the senior author, Reconstructive Review, and the Joint Implant Surgery & Research Foundation (JISRF). An example credit would be: "Courtesy of (senior author's name), Reconstructive Review, JISRF, Chagrin Falls, Ohio". While works can be downloaded and shared they cannot be used commercially.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work.